By any reasonable definition I am an AI doomer. It has nevertheless been historically very strange for me to see how closely associated "AI doomers" and short timelines have been in the popular imagination. As anybody who's interacted with the AI risk case will realize, timelines are (at least in theory) mostly orthogonal with your beliefs on AI safety. Yes, timelines have some impact on what kinds of interventions are going to be viable, but among people who "believe in AGI" the variance in their optimism about the problem is more immediately dependent on underlying technical questions than anything else. Before GPT-2 or AlphaGo, there was still a much smaller, nascent "AI safety community", and these people were certainly not basing their worries on some data about AI uplift that we only got in 2026.
However, for years people on general social media have taken it on faith that the "AI safety position" and "short timelines position" were the same, and even argued against short timelines as if in doing so they were arguing against "doomers." I actually don't think the AI safety people did much to promote this association in the beginning. Instead people would just assume that, if you were worried about AI, you must be worried about it happening in the next ten years, and therefore you must think LLMs scale to superintelligence all that there.
Personally, I don't have any inside view on how long it will take to get to superintelligence. I see remarkable progress, but I don't have a model for how optimizing verifiable metrics like pretraining loss perplexity or whatever will actually cash out into getting AIs to generalize much further, so I can't say whether current systems are going to get us to superintelligence, even if they can solve hard math problems. When I have encountered anti-short-timelines-conflated-with-AI-safety-people, I have historically responded [1] to them by explaining that we will eventually develop superintelligence, even if it takes twenty years, and that most of the theoretical reasons you should be worried about AI alignment will probably still apply. I then make the separate and distinct observation that skeptics of all stripes have essentially gotten the pace of AI progress wildly wrong, and so if your skepticism of AI risk is just that powerful AI will not happen soon, that seems really tenuous.
In the last few years, though, it sure has gotten a lot harder to make that argument, because a group of people who represent the AI safety community:
It was quite annoying to have to explain this last bullet to upwards of a dozen friends and relatives throughout the last two years, whom I do not think did anything wrong in getting a different impression. It was even more annoying to see the METR report come out, and almost everybody start to move toward ludicrously fast 6-12 month timelines based off of evidence that they're not even able to read.
I suppose it's possible that these people are right, and if they're right then I salute them for their bravery and intelligence. But I can't help but feel personally annoyed that the attention economy is structured such that all of the people that state aggressive timelines end up representing the clique. The only AI predictions people remember, on both sides, are the extreme Ege Erdil/Daniel Kokotajlo-type predictions that are surprising and/or turn out extremely wrong. Mostly people just remember the year that was quoted and not the probability you attached to it. And the people we most disagree with, in general, tend to have ludicrously long timelines, extending out decades . So when people publish extremely short timeline estimates, especially when those estimates are unendorsed "modal" years, it feels like we are playing the "guess the number out of ten" game, our opponents picked "17", and we countered with "1".
Yeah. It seems like a mistake strategically, and from the public-communications perspective, I'd say it's downright deontologically irresponsible. If you're taking on the mantle of keeping the public informed, if you want to earn their trust and deserve that trust, you have a duty to represent the danger accurately , instead of taking any opportunity to elevate it in their mind. Yet, I think people are being really epistemically sloppy on the topic, in a way that biases towards the latter. They can and should do better.
Edit: Also, is it just me, or cute dark gallows humor like this thread no longer feels appropriate? Like, those jokes were fine before the perceived situation got this stark, ha ha we may not see the next Christmas, "'how much do I have to live?' / 'five' / 'five years?' / 'four...'". Hilarious, I did laugh. But now that this is an actual position some serious people espouse, I don't find these funny at all, they're just contributing to a sense of panic in an unhelpful manner.
(Not to police how people in general are coping with the situation, but from high-profile public AI-risk speakers specifically this seems inappropriate.)

Loading comments…