There's a scene in the second episode of Mindhunter where Holden Ford, an eccentric FBI agent, is talking to Bill Tench, his straight-laced partner. Holden Ford has just interviewed Edmund Kemper, a convicted real-life serial killer, in prison. He's telling Bill about how mind-blowing the interview was, how Bill has to go back with him, and how the Bureau will learn so much about psychotic killers from talking to people like Edmund Kemper. And Bill Tench just says:
Look, there's no doubt that what happened to you in there was a very profound experience for you. But I need you to understand, that whatever you think, there's a distinct possibility, that he's manipulating you .
Holden Ford is vindicated [1] because Mindhunter is a TV show. But Bill Tench had the winner attitude. Whenever people tell you about how much that spiritual retreat changed them, it's bullshit. And I feel the same way that Bill Tench does about serial killers, about whatever internal locus of control people cede their brains to when they try to access their "inner self", for the purpose of writing or any other kind of spiritual activity.
One of the strongest [2] biases in the human race, is the tendency to assign external meaning to powerful feelings or spiritual experiences. In a way this behavior makes sense - emotions are important in their own right, and powerful emotions often do have a readily apparent cause. Even if there isn't an obvious source, these emotions usually accompany something important enough that developing a working theory or picking something random is positive expected value.
However, if you deliberately induce intense emotional states in yourself - either through meditation, drugs, or simply summoning experiences out of yourself for writing - you're displacing them from whatever signal is "supposed" to accompany them. You're not "accessing" any kind of true nature. You're just pressing the "insight" button in the mental soundboard. At best you're reprocessing some mangle of emotions you already experienced, but at that point why do the soulposting at all? You can just tell us all about that time something happened to you, and let us draw our own conclusions. We'll probably learn more about your soul while you're just explaining category theory, than when you're selling us on some particular reflective frame.
"Everyone is being their inner self all of the time" is not strictly true. I suppose you could have a nail in your head, and then it might be useful to distinguish the you that will be when you take out the nail, from the you that you are now. But the most distorting thing most people have to deal with on a day to day basis is the fact that public communication is inherently performative. Generally the best way to stop being fake is just to do something and let your true nature speak for itself.
Kind of? They catch a couple murderers together but I'm actually not sure how effective the show thinks criminal profiling is, given that it seems like they could have solved them all just by investigating them normally without the profiling work.
In the sense of powerful, not the sense of important.
I think soulposting could be useful for someone with a different cognition from you, people are different .
I believe many people are by default in a very strong "Match with the group" mindset, where they try to only day things that keep people around them happy.
But for writing it is more useful to tell the truth as you see it, without trying to appeal to the average of a group.
So for some people soulposting can be a tool to overcome the Voice in their head wanting to only say the Social consensus.
Seems like your model of emotions is that they are signals, and that inducing big emotions (that feel revelatory) is a bit like ramping up loudness in general, obscuring signal.
This view somewhat externalises emotion, and ignores effects like neural annealing , the idea that emotional intensity (and psychedelics) increases brain plasticity. Here, emotions impact the higher-order functioning of your cognition, a very different role compared to mere signals.
In this view, inducing peak experiences is a kind of plasticity lever, which might be situationally apt to pull, depending on situational factors. The way this trigger machinery evolved to act naturally is not necessarily the best use of it: we are outside our genetic training distribution.
The natural variant of this is posttraumatic growth, where people undergo huge personal changes after breakups or the death of loved ones. These natural triggers correspond to changes in load-bearing relationships, which seem like critical pivot points in our ancestral environment, given tribal power dynamics.
Now: is natural always better? It makes sense to avoid new-fangled unproven things, and rely on tried-and-true ways of doing things. However, we live in a very different world to the one we evolved to fit, so we can't rely on the natural operation of our cognition to be ideal. Humans have a special comparative advantage in dealing with context shifts: cultural evolution.
Using peak experiences to facilitate personal transformation seems to be a convergent phenomenon: rites of passage, meditation practice, etc etc. Personally, I'm pretty sure there's a there there, even though there's a lot of grifting going on.
I long for more rigour. I want big data analysis on meditation, rigorously nailing what works, in more places than jhourney . I want long-term outcome evaluations . I want society to prioritise personal growth, raising the sanity water line.


正在加载评论…